# | eng | mlg |
---|
1 | Slovakia: The “Work vs Money” Dilemma | Slovakia: Olana Momba Ny “Asa sa Vola” |
2 | SME newspaper published an article [sk] about a recent experiment in the city of Krompachy in East Slovakia. | Namoaka lahatsoratra [sk] momba ny fanandramana natao tao an-tanànan'i Krompachy any atsinanan'i Slovakia ny gazety SME. |
3 | Unemployed people were being asked to get involved in a public flood protection project. | Niangaviana hiditra amin'ny tetikasam-panjakana iarovana amin'ny tondra-drano ny tsy an'asa. |
4 | In this region with a high level of unemployment, only four young men agreed. | Ao amin'io faritra manana taha ambony amin'ny tsy fananan'asa io dia efatra monja ny tovolahy nanaiky. |
5 | All others refused, claiming that they'd be poorer if they took this job. | Nandà avokoa ny hafa rehetra, nanambara fa mbola mahantra kokoa ry zareo raha mandray io asa io. |
6 | The city calculated monthly budgets for local families with seven members - one where the husband accepted employment in the public sector, and the other where the husband was unemployed. | Nokajian'ny tanàna ny tetibolan'ny ankohonana ao an-toerana misy olona fito - ny iray lehilahy manambady nanaiky hiditra amin'ilay asam-panjakana, ny iray hafa kosa tsy an'asa. |
7 | They found that, because of losing some unemployment benefits and due to higher transportation expenditures, the employed man had 140 euros less than the unemployed one. | Hitany avy teo fa noho ny fahaverezan'ny tombontsoa azo amin'ny tsy fananan'asa sy noho ny fahalafosan'ny saram-pitanterana dia latsaka 140 euros noho ny an'ilay tsy an'asa ny volan'ilay nanaiky ny asa. |
8 | “And why do I have to work? | “Ka nahoana moa aho no tsy maintsy miasa? |
9 | To wake up every morning to go to work? | Hifoha isa-maraina hiasa? |
10 | They will take away the money [benefits] for child food, for housing and it is not a small amount. | Ho alain-dry zareo ny vola [tombony] solon-tsakafon'ny ankizy, ho an'ny hofan-trano ary tsy vola kely izany. |
11 | I prefer to not work and this way I will even save a few bucks,” Gejza, a father of four children, is quoted saying in the newspaper. | Aleoko tsy miasa raha izany ary mbola misy tahiry azo atao aza,” hoy i Gejza, rain'ny ankizy efatra notsongain'ny gazety. |
12 | What is left unsaid in the original newspaper article is that many Slovaks would assume that someone unemployed, father of many children, with a Hungarian given name and living in East Slovakia is likely a member of the Roma ethnic group. | Ny tsy voalazan'ny gazety dia ny fiheveran'ny Slovaky maro fa ilay olona tsy an'asa manan-janaka maro, heverina ho manana anarana Hongroà ary miaina any amin'ny faritra atsinanan'i Slovakia dia tahaka ny avy amin'ny foko Roma. |
13 | Spokeswoman of the Ministry of Labor, Social Affairs and Family said for the newspaper that “the Ministry knows about the badly tuned system of allowances for those in material need. | Niteny tamin'ny gazety ny mpitondra tenin'ny Minisiteran'ny Asa, Lalàna Sosialy ary ny fianakaviana fa “mahafantatra ny tsy fahatomombanan'ny rafitra fanampiana ireo olona mila izany ny minisitera. |
14 | Because of this, [the Ministry] has already made an effort to introduce changes, so that the recipient of state benefits had to deserve them. | Noho ny fisian'izany no niezahan'ny minisitera hampiditra fanovana, mba ho izay mendrika izany no omena azy. |
15 | Unfortunately, the proposal encountered opposition and did not make it to the negotiation stage. | Saingy indrisy moa fa nisetra fanoherana ny volavolankevitra ary mbola tsy tonga any amin'ny dingan'ny fifampiraharahana. |
16 | Anyway, we continue to look for an adequate system change.” | Na izany aza, mbola manohy ny fitadiavana ny rafitra mety izahay.” |
17 | Below are some comments from the article's discussion. | Ireto ambany ireto ny fanehoan-kevitra sasantsasany hita tao amin'ny lahatsoratra. |
18 | Element: | Element: |
19 | Even if it's 140 euro more for a working person, it will not help too much. | Na dia mihoatra 140 euro aza ho an'ny olona miasa dia tsy hanampy azy loatra izany. |
20 | Because for a man who has never been working in his life such a difference will not make him work. | Satria ho an'ny olona tsy niasa mihitsy hatrizay niainany dia tsy hahatonga azy hiasa izany. |
21 | Mrmr: | Mrmr: |
22 | An extremely […] misleading article. | Lahatsoratra […] mamitaka tanteraka. |
23 | It's not the social benefits that are high, but the wages - incomes - are low. | Tsy ny tombontsoa ara-tsosialy no ambony fa ny karama no ambany. |
24 | If they said that payment for flood protection work would be 1,000 euros per month, then the numbers and comparisons would look different… | Raha niteny ry zareo hoe 1000 eurros isam-bolana ny raisina amin'ny fiarovana amin'ny tondra-drano, dia ho hafa ny isa sy ny fampitahana… |
25 | Smeckar: | Smeckar: |
26 | Parental allowances should not be paid as a standard, but just like a deductible item from the wage. | tsy tokony ho lasitra ny fanampiana ara-bola ho an'ny ray aman-dreny, fa tokony ho tahaka ny singa miala avy amin'ny karama. |
27 | Those who do not work will get no allowances … otherwise you can't make people work… | Izay tsy miasa dia tsy mandray vola … fa raha tsy izany dia tsy mahavita mampiasa olona ianao… |
28 | buster234: | buster234: |
29 | Why would they go to work when we are working for them! | Inona moa no iasany raha miasa ho azy ireo isika! |
30 | And when there is a lack of money, they will have our social contributions increased! | Ary rehefa tsy ampy ny vola, dia hiakatra ny fandraisana anjara ara-tsosialy avy amintsika! |
31 | addis pareba: | addis pareba: |
32 | Badly tuned is not the system of allowances and social benefits. Badly tuned is the system of work remuneration. | Tsy ny volanjaza sy ny tombontsoa ara-tsosialy no ratsy fipetraka fa ny fomba fanomezana karama ny asa. |
33 | Tress: | Tress: |
34 | Who is writing that social allowances are too high? | Iza no manoratra fa ambony loatra ny fanampiana ara-tsosialy? |
35 | They are not. | Tsy izany ka. |
36 | Do you want to tell me that about 450 euros for a family with six members is [too] much? | Hilaza amiko ve ianareo ho be loatra ny 450 euros ho ana-fianakaviana iray misy olona enina? tsia. |
37 | It is not. It is necessary to increase wages and not to lower small benefits! | Ilaina ny mampiakatra ny karama fa tsy mampihena ny tombo kely madinidinika kosa! |
38 | djmaros (in reply): | djmaros (mamaly): |
39 | Someone is standing in your way? | Misy mijoro eo amin'ny lalanao? |
40 | Just ask your boss to add you 500 euros per month. | Mangataha amin'ny lehibenao hanampy 500 euros isam-bolana. |
41 | Will he? | Hanaiky izy? |
42 | treke: | treke: |
43 | For a parasite it is [too] much. | Ho an'ny mpitsentsitra dia be loatra izany. |
44 | For a person who cares about himself alone and is intentionally overeating and overdrinking the results of someone else's work, it is 100% more than necessary. | Ho an'ny olona miahy ny tenany manokana ary mikendry ny hihinambe sy hisotro tafahoatra ny tambin-kasasaran'olon-kafa, dia mihoatra noho ny 100% ilaina izany. |
45 | racional: | racional: |
46 | They encountered opposition? | Nisedra fanoherana? |
47 | Who are those opponents to lowering of the benefits for useless mouths? | Fa izany izany mpanohitra ny fampihenana ny fanampiana omena ny vavan'ny tsy miasa izany? |
48 | mudla (in reply): | mudla (ho valiny): |
49 | The opponents see it realistically. | Tena mahita ny zava-misy ny mpanohitra. |
50 | Where does that minister want to employ that unemployed to create merit? | Aiza no tadiavin'ny minisitra ampiasa io tsy an'asa io hampisy fahamendrehana? |
51 | How many unemployed do we have for one free job position? | Firy ny isan'ny tsy an'asa eto amintsika amin'ny toerana [asa] iray mitady mbola malalaka? |
52 | zeta reticuli (in reply): | zeta reticuli (ho valiny): |
53 | Where to employ them? | Aiza no ampiasana azy ireo? |
54 | Public works. | Asam-panjakana. |
55 | […] All the streets are shining […]. | […] Mamirapiratra avokoa ny arabe […]. |
56 | At least they will not steal and make children. | Farafaharatsiny tsy hangalatra ry zareo ary hanao zaza. |
57 | econoir.sk: | econoir.sk: |
58 | Don't be naive. | Aza dia tsotrabe e. |
59 | It's 400,000 of voters. | Mpifidy 400.000 io. |
60 | zeta reticuli: | zeta reticuli: |
61 | The solution is … when an unemployed person starts to work, he should not lose the whole allowance, it will just be lowered … This way it can't happen that a working person has less than a non-working one, however low his wages are. | Ny vahaolana … rehefa miasa ilay tsy an'asa dia tsy tokony esorina aminy avokoa ny fanampiana iray manontoloa, fa mba ahena … Amin'izay fotoana izay dia mba tsy ambany vola raisina noho ny tsy miasa izay miasa, na dia ambany aza ny karamany. |
62 | prdola: | prdola: |
63 | “Ministry: change is necessary” White people will work more and for less money. | “Minisitera: Tsy maintsy atao ny fanovana” Hiasa mafy kokoa ny olom-potsy ary ho amina vola kely kokoa. |
64 | Lionluck1971: | Lionluck1971: |
65 | I have just one question: how many officials our state needed to calculate what one unqualified Roma has been able to calculate? | Fanontaniana tokana: mpiasam-panjakana firy no ilaina hanao asa-marika vitan'ny Roma iray tsy avara-pianarana kajiana? |