# | eng | mlg |
---|
1 | Syria: Banksy’s Crude Politics | Syria: Politika Maloton'i Banksy |
2 | Banksy's video satirizing the Syrian civil war, entitled “Rebel Rocket Attack,” left Syrians and keen watchers of the conflict confused and disappointed. | Nampidanàka sy nandiso fanantenana ireo Syriana sy mpanara-maso akaiky ny ady an-trano ao Syria ny lahatsarin'i Banksy izay manaraby ny ady an-trano syriana, mitondra ny lohateny hoe “Rebel Rocket Attack,” [Fanafihan'ny mpikomy amin'ny balafomanga]. |
3 | The video, released on October 6, has since been viewed by over five million users on YouTube with over 25,000 likes and approximately 5,000 dislikes. | Mpisera maherin'ny dimy tapitrisa no efa nijery ny lahatsary tao amin'ny Youtube, izay navoaka tamin'ny 6 oktobra, ary nahazo “tiako (j'aime)” maherin'ny 25.000 sy “tsy tiako(dislike) teo amin'ny 5.000 teo izany. |
4 | Promoting the video, the anonymous British graffiti artist posted a trailer on Instagram with the following remark: | Mba hampiroboroboana ny lahatsary, mpanao sariitatra britanika tsy mitonona anarana namoaka sombina horonantsary tao amin'ny Instagram miaraka amin'ity fanamarihana ity : |
5 | I'm not posting any pictures today. | Tsy handefa sary mihitsy aho androany. |
6 | Not after this shocking footage has emerged. | Tsy taorian'iny lahatsary manafintohina niparitaka iny mihitsy. |
7 | Go to banksy.co.uk for the full video | Mandehana ao amin'ny banksy.co.uk raha hijery ny lahatsary manontolo |
8 | The trailer received over 3,000 likes and around 300 comments filled with mixed emotions. | Nahazo “like (tiako)” maherin'ny 3000 ilay sombina horonantsary ary fanehoan-kevitra teo amin'ny 300 teo izay feno fihetseham-po isan-karazany. |
9 | In what appeared to be amateur rebel footage, the spoof begins with two rebels aiming a hand held missile launcher at an object in the sky. | Amin'ity lahatsary tsy matihanina heverina fa avy amin'ny mpioko ity, ny fanombohan'ny lahatsary nalaina tahaka sy natao ihomehezana dia ahitana mpikomy roa miomana handefa balafomanga amin'ny tazoni-tanana mikendry zavatra eny amin'ny lanitra. |
10 | The actual audio is taken from a video of Mennegh Airport in Syria's war-torn Aleppo posted on February 23, as Nader pointed out. | Ny feo amin'ny lahatsary dia nalaina tamin'ny lahatsarin'ny seranam-piaramanidina Mennegh, izay ravan'ny ady an-trano tao Alep, ao Syria ary nivoaka tamin'ny 23 febroary, araka ny nambaran'i Nader. |
11 | A voice in the background yells, “Go back, go back, go back,” and another documents the footage saying, “God is the greatest; Aleppo's military council air defense battalion.” | Misy feo avy any ivelany nihiaka hoe “Miverena, miverena, miverena” afa amin'ny lahatsarim-panadihadiana hafa miteny hoe “Lehibe indrindra Andriamanitra; andia-miaramila miaro ny habakabaky ny filankevitra ara-miaramila ao Alep.” |
12 | Moments after firing, Disney's Dumbo falls from the sky, battered and bruised. | Fotoana fohy taorian'ny tifitifitra, nilatsaka avy eny amin'ny lanitra i Dumbo fahita amin'ny Disney, nipatitaka sy potipotika. |
13 | The masked rebels, wearing shalwar kameez, dance around and on top of the deceased cartoon character in celebration. | Nandihy manodidina sy teo amin'ilay olo-malazan'ny sarimiaina namoy ny ainy ireo mpikomy nisaron-tava, nitafy halwar kameez. |
14 | A child, dressed in a similar attire to the adults, enters the scene, looks at Dumbo and then kicks the rebel holding the launcher. | Niditra an-tsehatra ny ankizy iray mitafy tahaka ny olon-dehibe, nijery an'i Dumbo ary nandaka ilay mpikomy nihazona ny fandefasana balafomanga. |
15 | Throughout the video, the rebels are heard shouting the infamous Takbir, a chant often used by Islamists during protests and moderate Muslims praising God, “Allahu Akbar,” meaning God is the Greatest. | Nandritra ny lahatsary, re miventso ilay Takbir malaza ireo mpikomy, teny filamatra fampiasan'ireo islamista matetika mandritra ny fihetsiketsehana sy vavaka fiderana an'Andriamanitra ataon'ireo Miozolomana mahalala onony, “Allahou Akbar,” midika hoe Lehibe indrindra i Andriamanitra. |
16 | While the video left many wondering what “Allahu Akbar” means, it was also met with critical analysis of Banksy's leftist views. | Raha nampanontany tena ny maro ny lahatsary mikasika ny dikan'ny “Allahou Akbar”, niteraka tsikera ihany koa ny fijery mirona ankavia ataon'i Banksy. |
17 | The Washington Post's Max Fisher writes about the work's awkward politics: | Max Fisher ao amin'ny Washington Post nanoratra momba ny politika manorisory amin'ny sangan'asa : |
18 | Unlike his West Bank work, it's not really dealing with the conflict or its larger issues, even from a one-sided ideological perspective. | Mifanohitra amin'ny sangan'asany momba an'i Cisjordanie, tsy mitantara nloatra momba ny ady na ny olana lehibe kokoa ao Syria, na dia avy amin'ny fijerin'ny firehan-kevitra taritokana aza. |
19 | It's not getting to the core issues, but rather sticks on one of the few aspects that European and Arab leftist movements feel comfortable addressing, and ignores all the rest. That doesn't mean the video is bad or wrong as a piece of political art, of course | Tsy miresaka ny fototr'olana ilay izy, fa mijanona ao amin'ireo tranga vitsy fa mahazo aina ny Eoropeana sy ny Arabo ankavia, ka tsy miraharaha izay ambiny rehetra. Tsy midika izany fa ratsy ilay lahatsary na diso amin'ny maha-sangan'asa kanto ara-politika azy, marina izany. |
20 | Similarly, Syrian blogger Darthnader looks at the work through the eyes of Edward Said, adding that both imagery and context are offensive. | Tahaka izany ihany koa, ilay bilaogera syriana Darthnader nijery ny sanganasa tamin'ny mason'i Edward Saïd, ary nilaza fa samy manevateva na ny sary na ny votoaty. |
21 | He asks: | Hoy izy nanontany: |
22 | So what exactly is the message? | Inona marina no tena hafatra ? |
23 | That the Syrian regime warplanes are analogous to poor flying elephants? | Mitovy ny elefanta fadiranovana manidina ve ireo voromby mpiady an'ny fitondrana Syriana? |
24 | That the rebels in Syria are a bunch of ragtag buffoons going around trying to kill even the poorest creatures? | Andiana mpanao hatsikana hafakely ve ireo mpikomy ao Syria izay mivezivezy ka miezaka mamono ireo zavaboary marefo indrindra? |
25 | Twitter user MadeInNablus echoes his views: | Mpisera Twitter MadeInNablus nizara ny fijeriny: |
26 | Completely baffled by Banksy's new short vid on Syria. | Sanganehana tanteraka tamin'ilay lahatsary fohy vaovaon'i Banksy momba an'i Syria aho. |
27 | To me it has an air of orientalism about it. | |
28 | .savage allahu-akbar-screaming rebels etc - Made In Nablus (@MadeInNablus) October 9, 2013 | Mahare fofona tatsinanana aho. .mpikomy izay mihiaka ireo allahu-akbar olon-dia |
29 | Some even questioned the video's purpose, concluding that Banksy tackled an issue that he “does not understand enough about,” argues Lebanese satirist Karl Sharro on PRI. | Misy ireo manontany ny tanjon'ny lahatsary, manatsoa-kevitra fa niresaka lohahevitra “tsy dia fantany tsara izy”, araka ny hevitr'ilay Libaney mpanaraby, Karl Sharro tao amin'ny PRI. |
30 | Evidently, Paul Woodward of War in Context also says that it was devoid of any real meaning: | Miharihary ny nilazan'i Paul Woodward of War ao amin'ny “Context” fa tsy hita izay tena dikan'ilay horonantsary: |
31 | Banksy's latest stunt is just that: a stunt which calls for attention yet speaks of little more than the universal desire to be noticed. | Toy izao tokoa ny doka farany an'i Banksy : doka mitaky hojerena saingy tsy milaza zavatra betsaka afa-tsy ny faniriana manerantany ho voamarika. |
32 | It is a shout to be heard made by someone who has nothing to say - not a sharp piece of political commentary. | Hiaka mba hohainoana ataon'ny olona tsy manan-kolazaina izany - fa tsy zava-maranitra amin'ny fanehoan-kevitra politika |
33 | Others believed that Banksy sided with Assad, and condemned him for mocking a resistance that began with freedom graffiti. | Mihevitra ny hafa fa miaraka amin'i Assad i Banksy, ary niampanga azy ho maneso ny fanoherana izay natomboka tamin'ny graffiti momba ny fahalalahana. |
34 | Rana Kabbani tweets: | Rana Kabbani nisioka hoe : |
35 | #Banksy sides with #Assad. | #Mpomba an'i #Assad i #Banksy. |
36 | He 4gets that #Syrian revolution started with freedom graffiti, 4 which young boys had their nails pulled out. - Rana Kabbani (@RanaKabbani54) October 8, 2013 | Adinony fa ny revolisiona syriana dia natomboka tamin'ny graffiti (soratsoratra amin'ny rindrina) momba ny fahalalahana, izay nanesorana ny hohon'ireo tovolahy. |
37 | While some dismissed the video as a stunt, others emphasized that it only gained attention because of the international fame Banksy has gained over the years. | Nisy ireo nitsipaka ny lahatsary ho sangisangy, ny sasany kosa nanipika fa nahasarika ny saina izany noho ny laza manerantany ananan'i Banksy nandritra ny taona maro. |
38 | However, many others, specifically Syrians, did not care for it, as Twitter user Donatella points out: | Na dia izany aza, tsy mivaky loha amin'izany ny maro hafa indrindra ireo Syriana, araka ny filazan'i Donatella tao amin'ny Twitter : |
39 | The Banksy video: all my (non-Syrian) friends love it, all my Syrian friends havent seen it and dont give a damn about seeing it.. #Syria | Lahatsarin'i Banksy : ankafizin'ireo namako (tsy-syriana) ilay izy ; mbola tsy nisy nahita azy ireo namako syriana ary tsy miraharaha hijery izany akory izy ireo.. |
40 | - dona (@donatelladr) October 8, 2013 | |
41 | - Source of thumbnail | - Loharan'ny hajian-tsary |